I gave it a 9 based on the first two seasons.

Season 3 was rushed because it was getting canceled, so I'm not counting it.

 

I'd give it a 9.5 out of 10.


As great as the series was, it did have a few flaws. It's right up there with G and Beast Wars.

 

Ehhhh somewhere between a 6 and a 7. A lot of wasted opportunities. It was horribly unfocused in the first season and most of the second. Character development went in circles. It was a bit of a mess at times. Sure it was infinitely better than RID/A/E/C but still not as tight as BW/BM.

I would be tempted to take another point off just for the annoying and defensive fanboys. Perhaps in a few years the hype will wear down and they might be able to look at it logically and objectively.

 

Nine.

 

8.

It's not flawless but a very solid part of the franchise nontheless. Love it.

 

I give it a 9. There was a nice G1 look and feel to the show. Although there was some little kid silliness to it, I still very much enjoyed watching. There were weekends during the run when I was really excited to watch the show.

 

I gave it a 9. It was a great series with a lot of G1 references that made me grin ear to ear.

 

9 out of 10.

 

sixmillionbillionjillionwillynillyhilly........................or a 10

 

9 out of 10. In my eyes this series surpassed BW by just a hair, but falls below G1 simply because I feel guilty ranking anything higher than what started it all.

 

I gave it a 9 based on the Voice Acting and Writing. The Design/Art Direction kept it from getting a 10 in my book.

 

11. Pure, distilled awesome, plain and simple.

 

9. Not perfect, since it does have a few flaws.

 

10, because it's better than most of the recent series (looks at Unicron Trilogy).

 

10! probably my fav TF series.. although i've only watched the entire G1 and animated series, n nothing else..

 

9/10, mostly for showing a lot of respect to G1.

 

10 out of 10.

This is the first Transformers series that I would willingly watch. I loved it, I loved every moment of it. Surpasses Beast Wars in every way, from what I've seen, IMO.

 

I say about a 8
because some EP i did not like
but some were just great and perfect

 

6. I enjoyed it, but I can kind of see that I've moved past watching shows that are aimed at young kids. Not that it was terrible, but I did find it a bit predictable and formulaic without the nostalgia feeling I get from watching Beast Wars (first TF series I got into).

Those goddamn talking thumbs didn't help either.

 

9.
1 mark off for being cut off.