Best  
Leader Optimus Prime
Ejector!!!!



Worst  
Barricade (retool)
Breakaway

 

Of course if the deluxes merge to big bot that will gain them serious bonus points and eliminate them off the list but as of right now I'm assuming they don't.

and Sideways its a matter of a few paint apps would make him amazing he just looks lazy a uni color torso with solid color limbs just looks lazy

 

worst
devastator
arcee

best
sideswipe and
the mighty ejector burner of toast

 

Best
Voyager Screamer
Voyager Fallen

Worst
The Twins
Breakaway

 

I can only really comment once I have bought the figures, so here is what I've got for now:

Worst: 1. Preview Soundwave - absolute giant turd of a TF.

Seeing as that is all I have right now, that is the best I can do. I have high hopes for Leader Prime though.

 

BEST
Deluxe Sideswipe
Voyager The Fallen

WORST
Voyager Starscream
Deluxe Breakaway

 

I pretty much picked up everything, and I ain't too crazy about the Legends Starscream redeco and the Voyager Prime one. Everyone else gets brownie points.

 

Best:
1. Leader Prime
2. Deluxe Sideswipe OR HA Bumblebee OR HA Skids

Worst:
1. Leader Jetfire
2. the bikes or Leader Megs

wow really? thats the LAST one I thought people would put as best.....ok not THE last Supreme Dev takes that but you get my point

 

BEST
Leader Optimus Prime
Deluxe Sideswipe

WORST
Deluxe Breakaway
Scout Rollbar

I would've put Chromia up there, but I don't think that's entirely fair since we haven't seen the combined mode yet.

 

Leader Prime is a given, so I will choose my next two.

Best:
-HA Skids
-Scout Ejector

Worst:
-Devastator
-Chromia

 

Best:

My favorite so far has been Deluxe Sideswipe.
Scout Dirt Boss WAS my second choice, but now we've seen Ejector and I just don't know anymore.

Worst:

Supreme Devastator. $100 for something that looks better in the Legends class? Humph.
Desert Tracker Ratchet. Is there a point for this except to give people who missed him with the first movie a second chance?

 

Best:
1.) Leader Prime
2.) Sideswipe

Worst:
1.) Jolt
2.) Barricade retool

No, I didn't put Devastator. though that's basically what most people are gonna put as the worst.

 

Favorite (not necessarily best):
Dune Runner
Ransack

Honorable mention:
Legends Devastator
Ice Cream Twins

Worst:
Sideways
Arcee/Chromia

 

Best:
Mixmaster
Ejector

Worst:
Desert tracker Ratchet
Interrigator Barricade

I AM STRICTLY AGAINST REPAINTS THAT AREN'T EVEN REPAINTED!!!

 

Best
Leader Optimus (I don't like Movie Prime, but this interpretation is arguably ground breaking)
Deluxe Sideswipe (this is full of win sauce)

Worst
Leader Megs (just plain awful)
Leader Jetfire (This is hideous, plain and simple. Didn't have a chance due to the movie design (its ugly as sin). Not to mention, A record amount of kibble in alt mode)

 

reading this thread, Sideswipe is going to be tough to get ------------ 

 

Based on looks alone and not owning any...

Worst:
1. Chromia. Really want to like her but... just doesn't look good. I may end up wrong, though... hell, I thought Classics Mirage was AWFUL when I saw the unpainted proto way back in the day. Now he's one of my faves.
2. Leader Megatron. Just not impressed.

Best:
1. Deluxe Sideswipe. Damn, he just looks slicker than slick.
2. I want to say Leader Prime, but I think that Skids/Mudflap actually look like really cool toys. They're tied, I'm cheating, I know. I think the heads are fugly, but it just adds to their character... and I'm a sucker for that.

 

I don't own the figures, but based on what I've seen so far...

Worst
(1) Arcee - I'm hoping it's mistransformed in those pictures because otherwise, it just looks terrible...and I like how Chromia looks. If it's not mistransformed, the combination rumors had better be true, because there was a lot sacrificed in that design for something.
(2) Breakaway - I'm not keen on the aesthetic of the mold, but this colour scheme is atrocious and clashes something fierce. I might pick up a repaint somewhere along the line, just to have a version of the mold.

Best
(1) Sideswipe (Deluxe, not the crappy HA version)
(2) Deluxe/Voyager Constructicons, in general - Includes Demolishor, Rampage, Long Haul and Mixmaster, so far.

 

Worst:
-Ultimate Bumblebee
-$100 Mighty Morphin' Devastator

Best:
-Leader Class Prime, hands down.
-Deluxe Sideswipe behind Prime

 

WORST
Supreme Devastator
Ultimate Bumblebee

BEST
Leader Optimus
Voyager Fallen (I'm really looking forward to this guy)