Discussion in 'Transformers 3rd Party Discussion' started by bri888, Nov 17, 2019.
Which are your top 10 chug scaled 3rd party figures and why?
Kinda off topic in a 3rd party forum
We talking CHUG-scaled 3Ps? Like the early Fansproject? These days, even the lines that can cross over into CHUG also work with MP size. MMC's figures are all MP carbot-size and up, barring minibots like Nickel.
Fansproject Master V /improves lots on the G1 toy, making the character cool
Fansproject Sigma L /a fun reinterpretation with lots of character
Fansproject Severo /a great reinterpretation with lots of character
Toyworld Infinitor /faithfull representation
Toyworld Roar /idem
Toyworld Sludge /idem
ATF Titanium Saint /great likeness,fun toy, cool alt mode
MMC Anarchus /a toy with superior build and design compared to the usual MMC stuff while still being equally faithfull
MMC Kultur /Similar build and design to Anarchus, the only downside is the lack of wheels but it is a glaring downside
Unique Toys Warlord /a great chug Predaking at the size of standard CW combiner
While I agree some of mmc characters are larger then there chug counterparts, I disagree that it doesn't work with chug, my entire collection is built around mmc and Hasbro idw stuff. But as far as top chug goes the 30th Springer is definitely my number one from the mainline.
MMC Reformatted Azalea series
MMC Reformatted DJD crew
Fansproject Function-X headmasters
MakeToys Green Giant
MakeToys Defensor (forget the name atm)
Fansproject Causality Menasor set
Fansproject Causality Insecticons & repaints
Isn't Assaultus by FansProject?
My top 10 from what I've owned so far
1. MMC carnifex
2. MMC kultur
4.30th Hasbro springer
5.MMC feral rex combined mode
6.unique toys ordin combined mode
8.MMC aero alpha
Basically anything that's not masterpiece or legends scaled including the early fansproject stuff.
I've always equated CHUG to anything 3P that's considered "standard scale" by Reprolabels, or non-MP style transformations, but not Legends-scale. That being said, here's my top 10 official/3P CHUG scale (spoiler alert, most are some form of MTMTE character):
1. MMC Kultur (Tarn)
2. MMC Tyrantron (IDW Megatron)
3. LG-14 Ultra Magnus
4. MMC Calidus (Rodimus)
5. MakeToys Trashtalk (IDW Swerve)
6. MMC Carnifex (Overlord)
7. Thrilling 30 Springer
8. MMC Spartan (IDW Impactor)
9. MakeToys Rearend (IDW Tailgate)
10. FansProject City Commander + Classics Prime/Magnus
In no particular order.
-MMC Feral Rex
-Maketoys Striker Manus
-Maketoys Thunder Erebus
-Perfect Effect Rumble and Frenzy
Zeta Optimus Prime (Orion)
AFT Alpha Trion
Special mention to MMC Megatron
Seems I don't have a preference for any particular company.
MMC - Sky Lynx
MMC - Overlord
MMC - Fortis
MMC - Leo Dux
MMC - Talon
MMC - Bovis
MMC - Tigris
Mayhem Mechanics - Otomo
MMC - Megatron
FansProject - Slag/Slug
MMC Nero Rex
MT Striker Noir
MT Thunder Erebus
MT Devil Stinger
PE Xerxes Origin
PE Mega Doragon
Honorable Mentions: The rest of my collection that's displayed but wasn't mention from the Dark Counsel, their Combiners/Armies, and the Dragons
Personally I consider these 2 as MP scale.
PE Xerxes Origin
PE Mega Doragon
MMC and Plant X
i disagree on the case of that they are actually really short per the official scale chart, even "JIANG XING JX-METALBEAST-01 WINGED DRAGON" has admitted that their MP figure is half a head to small and their half a head to small is
a lot smaller than "MP" scale, every time y'all say PE is MP scale i wonder if y'all even know what that is at this point. Heck at this point everything is "MP" scale, every thread i'm in someone says oh that's car robot size so it's MP scale, oh that's MP10 size it's MP scale. MP is more than a scale it's a look that compliments that scale but everyone wants everything to be MP so they just say everything is MP.
The other is bigger doesn't mean this PE is CHUG. In my opinion, PE is perfect MP scale, just look at this pic.
That’s not even close to the proper scale.
I don’t really consider any big-er/voyager figures I have “chug” really.
I don’t own any more FP/MT early scout/deluxe bots either.
I mean, if I really had to reach, I’d say FP Stunticons were cool.
Separate names with a comma.