They're not, they're CHUG scaled. Using Impactor as a reference, he's roughly the same size as Thrilling 30 Springer, and they're the same size in the comics. Springer is roughly the size of an MP carbot. If he was in MP scale, he'd be at least the size of a Seeker and closer to Optimus' size. Their Sixshot is roughly MP10 sized, but with a significantly smaller head than MP figures that size, and in the comics he's HUGE; the MP scaled version of IDW Sixshot is Gcreations Fuuma which is LARGE. He's also too small to be Cartoon sixshot; I have DX9 Hanzo and he's 1-2 heads taller and significantly bulkier. Their Overlord is significantly bigger than MP10 and could work as an MP (I had it displayed with my MP cons before their ranks were really filled out) but, again, in the comics he's fucking huge... a real MP scaled Overlord would be as big as MP Victory Leo (MP Star Saber + KFC Simba combo) or even bigger.

HOWEVER, there ARE figures in the Reformatted line that ARE MP scaled: their Insecticons, which were originally part of their Ocular max line and was moved over because reasons. If that's what the original poster was thinking of, I can understand the confusion. But relative to the rest of the line they're WAY too big.

In general, MMC's Ocular Max line is their MP scaled line.

 

thanks for the input! i did have the mmc bugs included for the reasons you stated. i try to be as objective as i can with this guide.

 

After SGC, seems I may need to do a Legends guide!

New:
Fans Hobby MBJ-01 (Armada Optimus Prime)
Fans Hobby MB-12 (G1 Minerva)
Fans Hobby MB-13 (G1 Shūta Gō)
Magic Square MS-?? (G1 Toy Ultra Magnus)
New Age XM1 Mista (DOTM Soundwave, Ravage & Laserbeak)
X-Transbots MX-?? Dr. Egg (G1 Quintesson Judge)
X-Transbots B? Flipout (G2 Wildrider)

Updated:
Alien Attack *A-04* Zhukov
Fans Hobby MB-11 *God Armour*
Keith's Fantasy Club EAVI Metal Phase 12:B *Blackcloud*
Keith's Fantasy Club EAVI Metal Phase 13:B *Skyshock*
Maketoys *MTRM-17* Booster
TFC Abombinus moved to Alternative Note
TransProjectX Beast Commander *Gorilla*
X-Transbots MX-?? *X-Man*
X-Transbots *MX-XVIII* Herald

Released:
Fans Hobby MB-06B Purple Power Base
Fans Toys FT-28 Hydra

 

Brawn’s FT Hunk link goes to Beachcomber

 

New:
Perfect Effect PE DX06B Nemesis Gorira (Nemesis Beast Wars Optimus Prime)
ToyWorld TW-F?? Bounce Ball (BB Dropkick)
ToyWorld TW-F?? Crush (BB Shatter)
ToyWorld TW-F09 Freedom Leader (BB Optimus Prime)
Zeta BAR-01 King Chair for MP-36 Megatron

Updated:
Transform Element TE-01 *Op Leader*

Released:
Final Victory FV-02 Hummer
Final Victory FV-03 Reckless Combat
Final Victory FV-01 War Machine
Generation Toy GT-03 OP.EX (Hybrid Colorization Version)
Magic Square MS-01 Light of Freedom
Takara MP-36+
Zeta ZB-03 Silver Arrow

Corrected:
link for Fans Toys Hunk (thanks @mags2424)

Removed:
ToyWorld Thunderking (after seeing images, definitely not G1 inspired)

 

New:
Generation Toy GT-03B OP.EX (Nemesis IDW Optimus Prime)
Keith's Fantasy Club EAVI Metal Phase 6:A Crash Hog (G1 Wreck-Gar, Metallic paint)
Keith's Fantasy Club EAVI Metal Phase 6:B Dumpyard (G1 Junkyard, Metallic paint)
Perfect Effect PE-DX09B Psychro Knight (RID Cryotek)
+eta G1 Cartoon Head for Armageddon

Updated:
Keith's Fantasy Club *P-14 Raijin and Engine Power Master*
Keith's Fantasy Club *P-15 Grand Raijin*
Keith's Fantasy Club *P-16 Raiju*
X-Transbots *MX-14G* Flipout

Released:
DX9 D16 Henry
Fans Toys FT-17 Hoodlum
Transform Element TE-01 Op Leader
Zeta Toys ZB-04 Catapult

 

I love this list!!! =)

 

Thank you!  

 

New:
Fans Hobby MB-11A Black God Armour (Godbomber Recolor)
Hasbro MPM-9 Autobot Jazz & Sam Witwicky (TFM)
Takara MPM-9 Autobot Jazz & Sam Witwicky (TFM)
Hasbro MPM-8 Megatron (TFM)
Takara MPM-8 Megatron (TFM)
Takara MP-45 Bumble (G1 Bumblebee)
Takara MP-18+ Streak (G1 Bluestreak)
Takara MP-46 Blackwidow (BW Blackarachnia)
Takara MP-10 atmos "Duck Camo"
Takara MP-10 atmos "Elephant"
Takara MP-10 atmos "Viotech"
ToyWorld TW-C07H Dark Constructor (Devastator Recolor)
X-Transbots MM-VIIIG Arkose (G2 Beachcomber)
X-Transbots MM-VIII Arkose (Ver. 2) (G1 Beachcomber)
Zeta Z?-?? (G1 Predaking/Predacons: Divebomb, Headstrong, Rampage, Razorclaw, Tantrum)

Updated:
Generation Toy *GT-03B Noir* OP.EX
Takara *MP-47* Hound
ToyWorld TW-F01 *Knight Orion*
Need to Add Various Links

Released:
Fans Hobby MB-08 Double Evil
Generation Toy GT-03B Noir OP.EX
Mastermind Creations Ocular Max PS-04 Azalea
Zeta Toys ZB-05 Downthrust
Zeta Armageddon G1 Cartoon Head

 

On the first page, all of the links for the Aerialbots go to Toyworld Menasor. Can we get these fixed? I was actually looking for the Aerialbot page(s).

 

ZetaToys Kronos (Masterpiece Superion/Aerialbots)

I don't believe there are individual threads.

 

fixed, thanks

 

Added:
Civil Warrior General Grant (WW Optimus Prime)
Pro Design PD-31 Alt Mode Stand for Takara MP-29, Takara MP-29+ and Fans Toys Quakewave
Pro Design PD-30 Decal Upgrade Kit for Transform Element TE-01 Op Leader
Shockwave Lab SL-44 LED Upgrade Kit for MPM-5 Barricade
Takara MP-10ASL Convoy [atmos safari LEBRON Ver.]
Zeta-V ZV01 Pioneer (BB Bumblebee)

Updated:
ToyWorld *TW-F04 Dropshoot*
ToyWorld *TW-F04 Burst*
Added various links

Released:
Hasbro MPM-5
Hasbro MPM-6
Takara MP-20+ Anime Color Edition
ToyWorld TW-C07P Constructor (Metallic Green Version)

Corrected:
Fixed various links

Removed:
BB7/Yes Model Toys YM-?? (Bitsteam)
BB7/Yes Model Toys YM-?? (Hotlink)
Mastermind Creations Reformatted R-17 Carnifex

 

Agreed  

 

checking in on your baby?  

 

Always! They grow up so fast.

 

haha, good to know Papa is still around!

 

May I suggest
REFORMATTED R-50 SUPERMAX
as MP IDW Fortress Maximus

 

Is it in scale with MP? I know (overall) the Reformatted line is not meant to be MP scaled.

 

It will be 11' tall.
In IDW Fort Max is not a titan. He's more or less the same height of Ultra Magnus and Overlord (depends on the artist)
So I think this may work for MP scale.