Not to defend a scalper but $35 isn't worth it. Figure after tax, a $25 battle cat will cost $27 just to take it out of the store. Then ebay and paypal fees on top of that. He MIGHT make a few dollars 'profit'. Then there is the risk of an buyer pulling some shady stuff (not that you would). This assuming you would have had to pay shipping on top of the $35 offer. If it was free shipping, he's just lost money & he'd be better off just returning it to the store.