Few Autobots have managed grown on us the way Erector has over the years. Both Hasbro and iGear have made homages to this little guy using recolors of other toys, but who will be the last one standing?

Generation 1 Erector:


ROTF Mudflap:


vs.

iGear Shafter:

​

 

Shafter.
Somebody's been watch some ERB on YouTube...  

 

can i vote neither?

 

Mudflap.

 

I'm with prowl, we need a better line-up

 

Neither work for me. I love the G1 toy, and I have not seen anything really do it justice. I think if he had the same kind of showing the last Hall of fame vote as the one before there could had been more hope for a figure that was more true to G1. I guess I will have to make my own.

 

Neither here as well.

 

I didn't read this... it's supposed to be the better Erector, and not the better toy... neither for me either, even though I already voted.

 

I feel the Mudflap with a minicon would of worked better.Call the minicon Erecter and mudflap coulda been the crane/trailer battle station thing.

Shafter just looks to much like a recolored huffer.

I go with Mudflap.

 

Shafter is a better core figure, but lacks the accessories to be a better Erector. :\

 

out of the two shafter, but for a homage, neither really

 

As Erector? They're both rubbish.

 

Shafter but barely still can't believe I spent 40$ on him

 

Shafter is a Pretty decent Erector cab, he's just missing the trailer.

You could always use Energon Overload as his trailer...

 

I'm going neither as well.

 

where's the Neither function?

 

I noticed Shafter just got real cheap on ebay. Under $30 including shipping!

2012 Tfcon Canada Igear Shafter Rager Custom Repaint G3 Erector Henkei Classics | eBay

 

Neither really make a good Erector update.

As for which figure I prefer, Mudflap, but only after all the garbage is removed from his arms. With that stuff gone he's an incredible figure. I like the blue version better though.

 

None of the above.

As stand alone toys Shafty. That Mudflap is fuckng awful.