| I'm honestly not a fan of Welker. People treat him like a God but his TF voices are easily replicated by others. |

| I'm honestly not a fan of Welker. People treat him like a God ... |
| you are aware of his vocal talents beyond Transformers don't you? The gentlemen has done more voice overs for TV and Film than pretty much anyone. Also he is the master of animal noises and other things that sound so genuine you wouldn't believe it was coming from him. |
| Hell, if anything, the sheer range and number of voices he's done over his career should be enough to impress you. Yeah, there are people who can imitate a number of his voices, but you try and find me a single person who can do ALL of them. He's been doing voicework steadily for nearly 40 years, I think he's earned the accolades. And as to insight, this interview portion was mainly about the movie, and some more general questions on his voice acting career. You might find the next segment more interesting. |
| Any cartoon voice can be "replicated" by SOMEONE out there. That doesn't negate the talent of the originator of it. Can all of those people out there doing a Dr. Claw or Jabberjaw/Slimer voice actually...*act* as well as Welker, or cover the rest of his entire range? Nope. There's more to voice ACTING than just doing the funny voices. |
| Geewuners never fail to dissapoint "how did you feel when you lost the part of megatron to a BETTER VOICE ACTOR Hugo" Get over yourselves, G1 is over, |
| Geewuners never fail to dissapoint "how did you feel when you lost the part of megatron to a BETTER VOICE ACTOR Hugo" Get over yourselves, G1 is over, |
| Hell, if anything, the sheer range and number of voices he's done over his career should be enough to impress you. Yeah, there are people who can imitate a number of his voices, but you try and find me a single person who can do ALL of them. He's been doing voicework steadily for nearly 40 years, I think he's earned the accolades. And as to insight, this interview portion was mainly about the movie, and some more general questions on his voice acting career. You might find the next segment more interesting. |
| Seriously, this makes me not want to see the 2nd movie even more. I know I'll be blasted for being a "Geewunner" but Everytime I see Megs or read a comic with a G1 Megs in it, in my head it's Frank Welker talking. He's the original and everyone else needs to respect that. |
| Beyond the animal noises his voices are the same performances over and over again. He has a stable of like 5 speaking voices that he uses all the time. The more of his work I hear, the more I hear the same things over and over again. |
| Personally, I'm tired of people 'feeling' or 'sensing' anything about Welker's supposed tone in these redundant interviews. He's been answering the exact same copy & paste questions about not getting the Movie role since 2007, and he is ALWAYS professional & diplomatic when he states his opinion no matter how unimaginative the interview questions are. I truly think some of you won't be happy until he says "yeah, Bay was right, I suck and it would have been a horrible idea to cast me... G1 IS OVER afterall!". Geeezus. |
| Seriously, this makes me not want to see the 2nd movie even more. I know I'll be blasted for being a "Geewunner" but Everytime I see Megs or read a comic with a G1 Megs in it, in my head it's Frank Welker talking. He's the original and everyone else needs to respect that. |
| Any cartoon voice can be "replicated" by SOMEONE out there. That doesn't negate the talent of the originator of it. Can all of those people out there doing a Dr. Claw or Jabberjaw/Slimer voice actually...*act* as well as Welker, or cover the rest of his entire range? Nope. There's more to voice ACTING than just doing the funny voices. |
| you are aware of his vocal talents beyond Transformers don't you? |
| Christopher Lee has done 260+ movies, but 99% of them are crap. It's not the quantity, but the quality that counts. Frank Welker has done quality work, but G1 Megatron is not among that list. G1 Megatron was whiny and pathetic. NOT a warlord to be feared. His Galvatron was HORRIBLE. Galvatron sounded more like a disgruntled elf. Soundwave was only Doctor Claw from Inspector Gadget/Cave of Wonders in Aladdin. For a cheap 80's kid show, it works, for a multimillion dollar movie franchise headed by the leader in crap entertainment (Michael Bay), it doesn't. Sad when Bay can see things the fandom can't. |
| I think it's funny that he states that at no time did he actually get to walk in and audition for the Transformers movie ... if I read that right, at least. That he sent in something and they basically said "Yeah, no" and kind of didn't really give him the time of day. Sad. |
| Who interviewed Frank? I'm curious because I want to know what the interviewer meant by someone else voicing Ray Stantz from The Real Ghostbusters,the only person to have PLAYED Ray was Dan Aykroyd,Frank was the first Ray voice actor. |
| You're right, Ray Stanz hadn't been voiced in a cartoon before Mr. Welker did it. Still, he was a character that was previously established (as you said, by Dan Aykroyd) who Mr. Welker brought his own personal touch to, as he said. The question was slightly general, so as to include voice roles Mr. Welker has "covered" as well, such as Barney Rubble, Droopy, Dumbo, etc. |
...That's all I've got to say.
Looking forward to part 2...