Poll: What do you rate ROTF (Take 2)

Matt Starr · 07-04-2009, 07:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vengeance1701

That being said, I give it a 6. Let me edit that film and there's enough there to bump it to the 8/9 range.

The twins would barely have any lines, basically just be cameos. Most of the military scenes would be dropped. The parents would hardly be in it. No dog-humping, no Wheelie-humping. The 'spacebridge' scene would be spliced out with some stock footage of an SR-71 in flight. The wacky college stuff would be trimmed by half.

It'd probably come out about as long as the 86 movie but I think people would have enjoyed that more.

Sounds like you have a similar idea as myself and Destrongerlupus have going. Good luck with your edit!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mako Crab

I gave it a 4, but I've only seen it once, and I'm told it improves with added viewings.

* Lacking chracterization for the bulk of the robots. Didn't like the Twins at all.

* Plot and story development is really slipshod. I keep saying it feels like a script that's still in its first draft, and I stand by that (for the moment).

* Pacing and editing.

* Just felt like it was lacking a bit of heart, you know?

Same rating as myself, and about your last point...(sigh), unfortunately I know what you mean!

Gordon_4 · 07-04-2009, 08:13 PM

I give it a 7. Solid action set peices let down by some truly appalling middle sections and a few other things I've already voiced my concerns about elsewhere.

There was great, great potential here.

Pikatron · 07-04-2009, 09:46 PM

I gave it a 6. It was an enjoyable movie overall, but could've done with less bots, more storyline and character development and less crude humor (leg humping, steel balls and etc).