How dead is dead transformer? |
07-19-2008, 01:35 PM
|
#11 | | Decepticon Join Date: Nov 2007 Posts: 152 | Transformers: living organism?
Are you serious?!
They're not cyborgs. They are pure robots.
Here we go again with the stupid theory that TFs are almost like us people.
An artificial intelligence, even if smarter than us, is still artificial.
If Ratchet could do a backup of Optimus system memory, he could install an identical copy of Prime on another endoskeleton.
Problem is recreating a new body outside of Cybertron. |
| |
07-19-2008, 01:47 PM
|
#12 | | This space for rent. Join Date: Aug 2007 Posts: 1,272 Location: Singapore | Quote:
Originally Posted by luca_frontino Transformers: living organism?
Are you serious?!
They're not cyborgs. They are pure robots.
Here we go again with the stupid theory that TFs are almost like us people.
An artificial intelligence, even if smarter than us, is still artificial.
If Ratchet could do a backup of Optimus system memory, he could install an identical copy of Prime on another endoskeleton.
Problem is recreating a new body outside of Cybertron. | They ARE living organisms. Organisms does only mean cyborgs or carbon-based life.
"Autonomous robotic organisms" ringing any bells? |
| |
07-19-2008, 04:54 PM
|
#13 | | Decepticon Join Date: Nov 2007 Posts: 152 | Quote:
Originally Posted by Julliant They ARE living organisms. Organisms does only mean cyborgs or carbon-based life.
"Autonomous robotic organisms" ringing any bells? | That line is fictional.
I don't understand why you defend so strongly to have the TFs so human-like.
For you, they must:
- talk like humans
- move like humans
- die like humans
Can't they just be stealth robots? It would make them feel more realistic. |
| |
07-19-2008, 05:37 PM
|
#14 | | This space for rent. Join Date: Aug 2007 Posts: 1,272 Location: Singapore | Quote:
Originally Posted by luca_frontino That line is fictional.
I don't understand why you defend so strongly to have the TFs so human-like.
For you, they must:
- talk like humans
- move like humans
- die like humans
Can't they just be stealth robots? It would make them feel more realistic. | Everything in Transformers is fictional. Transformers are fictional.
Wait a minute - you DON'T want Transformer that talk, move or die like humans? So they should speak in Cybertronian all the time, have 6 legs and crawl along the ground, and vaporize when they die. Transformers have ALWAYS been human-like. They have a head, bipedal form of 2 legs and 2 arms. I don't know any Transformer that doesn't move like a human while in robot mode. As highly sophisticated creatures with sentience and a large body, it would make sense to have more than just simple "battery and computer" aka spark and brain.
ALL living creatures have more than that. Even ants have more than just a heart and a brain. They have glands and rectum etc. It would make sense that a Transformer would have more than a spark chamber and processing unit. An energy absorbtion unit? An internal cooling system? A nervous system? This is the movie-verse. It's already established this isn't like Beast Wars or any other cartoon series - Transformer WILL die and they're not as tolerant as to survive being blown to tiny little bits. This more realistic approach can be rationalized if movie-verse Transformers aren't that simple and are very complex like a real multi-cellular organism should.
And what do you even mean by 'stealth robots'?
Typo: Organisms does *not* only mean cyborgs or carbon-based life |
| |
07-21-2008, 07:29 AM
|
#15 | | Au contraire, Blackadder. Join Date: Aug 2006 Posts: 1,746 Location: Halifax, W Yorks Collection Count: 300+ at a guess | I find that transformers are generally only as dead as the writer wants them to be. Anything from 'dead is dead' to 'easily restored' and between is possible in the TF universe, just depends on how the particular writer feels.
And once again, I must point out that it's the human qualities of TF characters that have made them so enduringly popular and able to inspire 20+ years of devotion from their fans. |
| |
07-21-2008, 10:07 AM
|
#16 | | Release the Kraken!!!!!!! Join Date: Dec 2007 Posts: 1,153 Collection Count: 100 or so... | Quote:
Originally Posted by aussiehippy I find that transformers are generally only as dead as the writer wants them to be. Anything from 'dead is dead' to 'easily restored' and between is possible in the TF universe, just depends on how the particular writer feels. | Yep... see: TF the movie's Prime dies from severe wounds, while Ultra Magnus (who was blown to PIECES) is put back together in minutes and better than ever! That's just ludicris, BUT it's what serves the story needing to be told... I think. |
| |
07-21-2008, 10:08 AM
|
#17 | | Maximal Join Date: Feb 2008 Posts: 329 Location: Australia Collection Count: Want Protoform Optimus... WAAAANNNNTTT! | Quote:
Originally Posted by aussiehippy I find that transformers are generally only as dead as the writer wants them to be. Anything from 'dead is dead' to 'easily restored' and between is possible in the TF universe, just depends on how the particular writer feels.
And once again, I must point out that it's the human qualities of TF characters that have made them so enduringly popular and able to inspire 20+ years of devotion from their fans. | That and quiet a few of the popular ones have very strong well defined personalities for people to connect with/find interesting. 
Deviant Art page
|
| |
07-21-2008, 12:47 PM
|
#18 | | Decepticon Join Date: Nov 2007 Posts: 152 | (referred to human-like TFs):
Whatever... for me is just lame. |
| |
07-21-2008, 01:16 PM
|
#19 | | Banned Join Date: Mar 2007 Posts: 1,499 Location: Bout' to move to Bo-oulder Colorado! Collection Count: 43 (counting Mini-cons) Latest figure: Cybertron Galvatron | Quote:
Originally Posted by luca_frontino Transformers: living organism?
Are you serious?!
They're not cyborgs. They are pure robots.
Here we go again with the stupid theory that TFs are almost like us people.
An artificial intelligence, even if smarter than us, is still artificial.
If Ratchet could do a backup of Optimus system memory, he could install an identical copy of Prime on another endoskeleton.
Problem is recreating a new body outside of Cybertron. | They've always been living sentient organisms. They're essentially mechanical organisms. Secondly they're not artifical. Quote:
Originally Posted by Julliant They ARE living organisms. Organisms does only mean cyborgs or carbon-based life.
"Autonomous robotic organisms" ringing any bells? | This. Quote:
Originally Posted by Julliant Everything in Transformers is fictional. Transformers are fictional.
Wait a minute - you DON'T want Transformer that talk, move or die like humans? So they should speak in Cybertronian all the time, have 6 legs and crawl along the ground, and vaporize when they die. Transformers have ALWAYS been human-like. They have a head, bipedal form of 2 legs and 2 arms. I don't know any Transformer that doesn't move like a human while in robot mode. As highly sophisticated creatures with sentience and a large body, it would make sense to have more than just simple "battery and computer" aka spark and brain.
ALL living creatures have more than that. Even ants have more than just a heart and a brain. They have glands and rectum etc. It would make sense that a Transformer would have more than a spark chamber and processing unit. An energy absorbtion unit? An internal cooling system? A nervous system? This is the movie-verse. It's already established this isn't like Beast Wars or any other cartoon series - Transformer WILL die and they're not as tolerant as to survive being blown to tiny little bits. This more realistic approach can be rationalized if movie-verse Transformers aren't that simple and are very complex like a real multi-cellular organism should.
And what do you even mean by 'stealth robots'?
Typo: Organisms does *not* only mean cyborgs or carbon-based life | True. Transformers have every characteristic of a human, the only two differences are. They're mechanical and they can turn into vehicles, plus they can do even more than humans can do. They have internal organs similar to ours, they are humanoid beings. Why can't some people just accept that fact? |
| |
07-21-2008, 08:01 PM
|
#20 | | Combaticon Join Date: Sep 2004 Posts: 2,296 Location: NEW JERSEY!!!! Collection Count: I don't have enough fingers and toes... | I look at it this way. Transformers is a comic/cartoon based movie. Just like Spiderman, X-men or the Hulk, etc.
In other words death is merely an inconvenience.
Prof X is still alive, so is Doc Oc and Venom, and most likely so is Jazz ,Megatron, Brawl, and all of the gang. |
| |
Similar Threads | | Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post | | I'm not dead. | Mr. Jiggles | General Discussion | 20 | 03-15-2008 04:39 PM | | G1 is dead | Ironhide2005 | Transformers Movie Discussion | 3 | 04-16-2007 09:43 AM | | My GBA is DEAD | Kickback | Video Games and Technology | 18 | 09-28-2006 09:05 PM |
Posting Rules
| You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts HTML code is Off | | | | Tools and Information | | | | | | | How dead is dead transformer? Page 2. Transformer World 2005 is the largest fan community related to Transformers toys. Features information on Transformers 2, the sequel to the Transformers Movie, Transformers Animated, Classics 2.0, Optimus Prime and Megatron. Daily news, toy resources, galleries, Transformers wallpapers and more are available.
Check us out for Transformers, Transformer, Transformers 2, Transformers Movie 2, Transformers Movie, Transformers Animated, Classics 2.0, Transformers Universe, Transformers Toys, Transformers DVD, Transformers Wallpapers, Transformers Images, Transformers News, Transformers Resources, news, sequel, Transformers Comics, Optimus Prime, Megatron, Bumblebee. |  |