All three of them are great in my opinion. BUY THEM ALL!

 

There's Energon Ultra Magnus... If you could find one.

 

I'd go with titanium ultra magnus. Looks more like the G1 than RiD and fits better with the classics line than animated

 

Yeah, who's just a strait repaint of Armada Overload. You may as well build a patio with 'em because he's a brick.

 

Animated is way better than RiD. I was considering buying an Animated Magnus for my Classics before I managed to find a City Commander for its original price

 

for a classics look, City Commander is your best shot, though until i got him i actually was using my RiD Magnus. Animated just doesnt fit in with tem, though Animated is also the one i lay with the most. hope that helps