Discussion in 'Transformers General Discussion' started by iwasherenotyou, Jul 3, 2009.
Yahoo! Users' Top Rated Animated Films - Photo Gallery on Yahoo! Movies
its ranked 30
Nice it made the list.
hmmm nice to see it made the list but other than that i struggle to find anything good to say about the list, its dominated by Disney/Pixar films and is way slanted towards the the most recent animated films espeically at the top and many i felt should be on the list aren't there for example Bambi and Fantasia both should be on the list
Yeah, I feel that in order to qualify for one of these "lists" the movie should be at least 10 years old. How can something that was JUST released be #1?
They have to be out of their minds.
By being better than all that came before.
Just because it's old does not make it better. I am not saying this list is correct. I am just saying all time counts now.
How can it be judged instantly better? I'm just saying that a new movie hasn't earned the right to be considered " One of the best of all time" as it hasn't been tested against any time at all.
I agree it should be on the list.
That list is heavily flawed.
But at least Transformers the Movie and The Simpsons Movie are on there.
But where's the SpongeBob movie??!
Definitely a lot of voters for that list are in their twenties, teens, tens, or single digits.
It's neat that the TF movie made that list, but I'm more than a little dismayed that only two other films on that list are older than it.
I did like that the TF film is "set in the futuristic year of 2005" though.
I still think it has some of the best animation to date.
The '86 film is fun to watch at parts but it is not, by any means, a good movie.
Bolt and WallE higher than Lion King obviously indicates there was some kind of error in tabulating the results.
I think it's a good cartoon movie - entertaining and dramatic. The bit where Megatron jumped backwards and turned into a gun was hot as hell. (I'm a girl).
Agreed!!! I find the animation in Transformers the Movie to be absolutely breathtaking.
But then again I'm a sucker for "older-looking" animation (I also love the look of the Simpsons in like season 3-8, not this digital crap).
while I agree that most of those are good (with the exception of Finding Nemo) something is really fucked up when movies like Toy Story and Lion King arent ranked higher
definitely I loved both but Lion king was and still is awesome
There were definitely some annoying characters (wheelie) but other than that it was a good movie. Think it should have been rated a little higher though.
'The Simpson's Movie' and 'Shrek' are ahead of TF86? Riiigghhht.
"Arise Rodimus Prime" - I don't care what anyone says the that part where Hot Rod became Rodimus and Optimus said that, blew me away as a youngster!!
Separate names with a comma.