Ok...I Know similar situations have been discussed, but I want some opinions. Here's my situation: I bought a G1 Shockwave in box on ebay and received the package today - I opened it up, and the clear plastic on the Shockwave box was ripped pretty severely (the rip continued about a 1/2 inch through Shockwave's chest but isn't as noticeable). Upon further inspection the packaging box had a "hole" punched in it. I emailed the seller to clarify that the Shockwave box was not like this when sent (it was not listed in the description and the pictures didn't appear to show it like that, but sometimes it's hard to see the clear plastic in ebay pictures). I haven't heard back yet, and it doesn't appear to be the seller's fault, but not my fault either - so I don't want to get caught up paying for return shipping on something that isn't my fault. Wondering if you guys would demand a full refund with the seller to pay shipping? Or what you would do if the seller refused a return? Or if you would ask for a partial refund?