Probably played on mainstream rock station anywhere between 95-97. 92.3 K Rock where I was in NY. It had a very X-files theme vibe to it, I remember they played the hell out of it around Halloween too...for the life of me I cannot recall the name or artist. If you have any idea, post it here!
The X Files Theme DADO Paranormal activity mix from pure moods. Amazon.com: Pure Moods, Vol. I: Various Artists, Adiemus, Angelo Badalamenti, David A. Stewart, David Byrne, Deep Forest, Enigma, Ennio Morricone, Enya, Eight Others: Music Not sure but seems like it might be it.