1.) So if you had the time machine right now would you still choose weaving over welker knowing what it sound like now. 2.) Second is IF (big if ) megtron lives for the second movie could the damage done to the area near his voice box make a nice entrance for welker as a voice change or would that be to drastic a change in character. After hearing how few lines and how Weaving sounded alot more like Leonard nemoy's Galvatron, I still can't figure out why they wouldn't go with Welker. I think Welker's voice had more depth and dimension to it plus the identifiable nature of it actually being the original voice would have been much better. I think Weaving gets way to much credit and pub for the vanilla voice job. obviously I'm pro welker in this but my reasons are valid as someone who works in sounds and effects alot I can see the welker voice being much more intriguing and just as believable with the same effects that were used for weaving with out the kiddie aspect as so many have sighted. EDIT: I think what I am going to do as I have read the posts here is try to take some of the content either from the new game or some old G1 samples and try to make it go Hollywood with some good ol fasion sound FX work then post it here and no it would just be a cheap echo or flange. Then we can see what people think cause the problem is they are thinking welker as the cartoon you need to envision him with more direction and same effects that weaving was given.