Discussion in 'Movies and Television' started by Hotshotprime43, Aug 11, 2012.
Who do you prefer as Rachael in the Batman movies.
I think Katie Holmes is better
Katie Holmes is maybe easier on the eyes.
But as an actress? As a believable character?
Has to be Maggie.
I really don't think either was particularly good or bad, but the character was pretty uninteresting to me anyway. I'd give a slight edge to Maggie Gyllenhaal.
Certainly, Katie Holmes.
I'm gonna go against the grain here. It's Maggie for me both in talent AND looks. Where this nonsense pops up that she's ugly I will never understand.
Maggie Gyllenhaal is the better actress, but Holmes is more attractive.
Gyllenhaal on both counts by far.
Katie Holmes looks better but Maggie can act better.
I don't know what people see in Maggie that she is beautiful, I'm sure she is nice and all and she is the better actress but her eyes are oddly shaped and she kindo f has this moonface thing going on
Not a fan of Holmes. Maggie has my vote.
Both of them. Covered in jelly.
Maggie by far. Having just rewatched BB & TDK, it's literally like night and day. I'm disappointed that Nolan hasn't gone all Lucas Crazy and CGI'ed Maggie into BB.
Maybe for the trilogy BR boxset...
Maggie. Katie always looked way too young, like she was ten years old.
Neither. I flinch every time either of them appear on screen.
Holmes looks like the mouse from An American Tale
Holmes, Maggie was just a tool that showed the audience how crazy Joker really was.
lol, that's awesome and accurate.
If by 'better' you mean which one do I find more attractive and probably start stalking because I recently found out she's single then Katie Holmes.
Separate names with a comma.