Discussion in 'Transformers General Discussion' started by Golden Age, Jul 11, 2006.
In a fight to the finish, who would win?
My money is on Grimlock.
Considering BW megs is like 8 feet all and Grimlock is close to 30ft... yeah, I think Grimlock would take him.
Considering Grimlock is big enough to step on Megatron like he's a bug, I'm also voting for Grimlock.
It's a one sided fight Grimlock all the way unless he's in statis lock asleep on the Ark
BW Megatron is too smart to get himself pulled into a straight up one-on-one fight with G1 Grimlock. He'd come up with some way to catch Grimlock at his weakest, or lure him into a trap, or some other scheme that would only fail if the "badguys always lose, good guys always win" rule were still in effect.
But yeah, in a simple mano a mano fight, Grimlock would annihilate the much smaller Megatron.
Poor, poor Megs. So many schemes and plans foiled by cartoon logic.
Man, even if they were the same size Grimlock would take him. Grimlock is just way too baddass. Especially if we're talking Marvel comics Grimlock.
But, they're nowhere near the same size, so Grimlock steps on him, end of fight.
I couldnt have said it better.
G1 Megs wouldnt even stand a chance against Grimlocks sheer rage. Despite all BW Megs intelligence he would not stand a chance. In crossing the rubicon we saw how small Megatron was compared to G1 Transformers like hound, and G1 Transformers like hound are like half the size of Grimlock. So it would be like a frog vs a polarbear.
G1 megs would rape grimlock if were talking about the most original of continuities(The comic) which is it comic grimlock or the stupid cartoon grimlock.
Where's DragonTerratron to argue that BW Megs could beat anybody? Those were fun to read.
Now, G1 Grimlock in his BW body vs. BW Megatron, that could be interesting.
What we know from IDW's miniseries:
A) TM Megatron appeared to be physically more powerful than Magmatron in robot modes
B) In beast modes, Magmatron proved to be more than BW Grimlock could handle (3 vs. 1 factor). Perhaps in robot mode the outcome would have been different, but we may never know.
So, while there are still several unknowns, based solely on their performances against Magmatron, I'd say that TM Megatron would have the upper hand against BW Grimlock.
If it's Marvel or Dreamwave Grimlock, Megatron II doesn't stand a snowball's chance in a supernova.
If it's cartoon Grimlock, Megs would probably be able to hold his own long enough to get the upper hand. If it was after the movie, where he became not just stupid, but lovably handicapped, Megatron would destroy him.
Of course, Beast Wars loosely follows Marvel continuity, so Grimlock would likely be at half or full badass. Megatron could win, but it would only be through a convoluted series of Machiavellian machinations that would only be revealed when necessary and leave everybody thinking that the writers just made it up because they wanted Megatron to win.
Ah, if only I knew the comics.
TM2 Megs might stand a chance, I think he's supposed to be closer in size to G1 guys after the upgrade. But not big enough I think, so Grimmy would probably still win. BW Megs was way more about being clever than being brutish.
I share the opinion with many of you guys that in whatever form, (comics or show) G1 Grimlock will beat BW Megs if its 1-on-1 fight.
YOu know in that fight why can I hear Grimlock sayin g
"HA HA YOU PINK PUSSY!"
I dunno why I just can.
me grimlock bash brains
Grimlock!! BW Megs has a rubber ducky!
I'm right here. I've made the decision not to post here anymore; but then you had to go and mention me by name
I'd love to just end the post here, but that would be spam-alicious, so I'll lend some of my memorable insight to the thread. The OP was very scant for details however.
Which version of BW/BM Megs?
Which version of G1 Grimlock?
New American comic(s)?
There's no less than 20 different fights described simply by saying "BW Megs v. G1 Grimlock". I would advise you all to settle on one of those twenty before the thread goes much further, otherwise you'll probably find yourselves picking whichever version is most advantageous to your favorite of the two, and procaliming victory for your chosen character because of the scenario you hand picked.
And with that, I must strip naked and immerse myself in falling water before going to work.
"Grimlock smash little barney!"
Seriously, I think BW Megs (in any form) would win, simply because he has the brains and a dramatic flair. Grimlock would just be too straightforward and predictable. Kind of like bringing a knife to a gunfight: dangerous up close, but absolutely useless nonetheless.
Separate names with a comma.