Discussion in 'Transformers General Discussion' started by mrgalvaprime, Nov 1, 2011.
Which do you think?
G1 cartoon Rumble is blue, G1 cartoon Frenzy is red.
Pretty much every other Rumble is red, pretty much every other Frenzy is blue.
I don't care for the G1 cartoon, so yeah.
omg not this again
thats what I was thinking.
honestly, its not a matter of what someone thinks. the toy names were the opposite of the cartoon names. so technically, they are both frenzy and they are both rumble.
personally, i go with the cartoon, rumble is blue. frenzy is red. but thats just me
Cartoon is wrong, this is fact, but people still go along with the cartoon on nostalgic reasons, so it is a hopeless battle to correct the misinformed cartoon lovin masses
No it is NOT a fact that the cartoon is wrong.
Unless you recently found info that proves it was a mistake and not a deliberate change.
g1 story bible declares Rumble is Red and Frienzy is blue, its was an animation error that they just ran with
again, i don't want to fight over this dumb shit, AGAIN, just stating the facts
Rumble is blue yo.
Sorry, but that proves nothing.
Yes, he was planned to be red, but the toon animators made quite a few changes.
problem is you have stated no FACTs in regards to wether it was an animation error or a deliberate change.
care to try again?
No, i don't CARE to try again, seriously, this argument is a load of bullshit, the facts are that when the characters was conceived, in comic and toy form FIRST rumble was red and frenzy was blue, and that was the intended purpose for the show, but for some unknown reason the animators were high or something and decided, "lets just swap them, you know, for lulz".
its just a bunch of nonsense that could easily be fixed by never making a blue rumble EVER, and so far they haven't (RTS does not count, it never came out, thank god, glad that mistaken name never saw the light of day, last thing we need is g1 cartoon purist jumping down our throats shouting "SEE!?!?!?! RUMBLE IS BLUE!?!?! lets forget every other rumble and just focus on this one!?!??!!?!")
The cartoon is always wrong!!!!!!
then stop making claims that you cant back up 100% beyond any doubt and saying they are FACTS
but that does not prove the show made an animation error and not a deliberate change.
your not exactly right here either.
Both the Diamond Select wall plaque of Soundwave and their Mini Bust line feature a Blue Rumble.
was sculpted by Art Asylum and limited to 1,000 pieces. He is seen emerging from the space bridge with Rumble, Laserbeak, and Ravage in tow
thats an opinion not fact
Woah the results of the votes are quite suprising
well, you only got about 14 votes so far
He actually did. Show bibles are exactly what they sound like. If it differs from that it's technically an inconsistency, not a deliberate change.
However I don't give a shit about that. I consider Rumble red and visa versa based on the toys and fiction they appear in. When the number of blue Rumble toys exceed the number of red, I adjust accordingly.
I'm honestly surprised this shit is as big as it is considering Rumble and Frenzy are such bland minor characters.
Only thing I am surprised about is no one ever puts the "who gives a shit" option on so I can actually vote in one of these polls that show up every two weeks....
I take that back.. I am not surprised at all.
He actually did....NOT. Show bibles do tell us what they originally planned, but they dont always tell us everything that happened from the point of conception to the finished product.
Just look at show bibles from other shows and you can see major differences.Heck, just look at the early steps into the making of the 86 film.How many things were changed?
I've said it before and I'll say it again, in 20+ years I havent seen anyone provide any evidence it was an animation error and not a deliberate change.
I personally follow the toy's/original comics as well
gotta love how this debate resurfaces every few cycles.
but let it be stated once and for all: rumble is blue, frenzy is red!!!
Separate names with a comma.