1. Box- 10 Box is impeccable and extremely tight- the flaps taped down on the sides so tight the box had no give to it. i liked that. 2. Packaging- 10 simple and clean. The bag with the sticker sheet, instructions and errata was well concealed behind the white cardboard insert. The multi layered plastic casing to hold toy and accessories in place was a nice touch. 3. The toy- 8 Transformation process was simple and easy, joints on arms were starting to loosen after a few transformations. my biggest gripe has to be with the tank treads on the gun platform. during the first transformation, one of them popped off. it isn't a break, it simply pops back onto a peg, but it does come off rather easily. makes me want to keep Ratchet in box and on the shelf, which is a shame. Overall, I am pleased with what i got because the experience of opening a genuine TF again for the first time in decades was worth it. recommend this one to you all.