Two of the most common criticisms I hear about Rosie/Carly are the following: 1. Rosie can't act. 2. The scene at the beginning of the film (where Carly walks up the stairs in her underwear) is nothing but soft core porn for the testosterone raging male audience. In regards to #1 above, I thought Rosie did a decent job of acting - especially for an actress in her first film. For those who disagree, why? Don't just say she was terrible, give me reasons and examples. All I ever see is comments like "Rosie can't act, she's just eye candy" etc. No one ever points out a particualr instance where her acting was sub-par. Plus I get a kick out of all of us nerds who are now suddenly acting experts who know the craft inside and out. Give me an example of where her acting was not good. I tought she did an adequate job. In regards to #2 above, how many films have random nudity in them? The list of movies with random nudity in them could go on and on. Yet those films get a free pass and Transformers (which doesn't have any nudity) gets blasted for catering to the testosterone raging male audience? Please explain why I'm an idiot and the two criticisms above are valid.