Yea I know threads like this are doomed to get closed because of the way fans love to fight, but I was sort of wondering about what people thought and hey it might be fun while it lasts. One of the complaints some of us have about the first film is in the writting department. Not going to get all flamey about it, some of us just didn't like it. But are the writters really to blame for the problems some of us might have had with the script of the first film. We know one of the producers wanted the boy and his car story put into it. We know the director was set on getting some of the things he wanted into the script. Can't remember exactly where Orci said it but there was the thing about how the suits didn't want the robots to talk at all. There was the meeting thing to inject more comedy into the script for the first film. Who knows what all Hasbro wanted injected into the movie. So I guess what I'm saying is that if you were making a soup and people kept coming by putting things into the pot is the finished soup really your fault or is the problem you had a good soup before people started throwing things in it? On sort of a related note do you think the second film will have a better story, script, and all of that if people are more hands off this time and actually let the guys write instead of attempting to put stuff in? Thanks for how ever long this thread lasts.