Hi I wanted to let everyone know about the afa graded sludge that was on ebay that was a possible knock off. The thread for this was http://www.tfw2005.com/boards/transformers-ebay/306323-dinobot-sludge-afa-bootleg-ebay.html The Sludge has returned from AFA and I have confirmed the following: -The AFA case was a knockoff and is now in AFA hands as they wanted the case for their information. -The Sludge is a genuine item in a sealed box and has been graded as a AFA 80. I was extremely happy with the result and has boosted my confidence with AFA grading. I wanted to let everyone know as I do not want to be seen as a Dodge seller and to resolve this matter once and for all. Let me know you comments.