Accident in football town elicited threats, not get-well wishes

Rodimus Prime · Dec 20, 2006

Boy hurt by cannon blast feels twice wounded
Accident in football town elicited threats, not get-well wishes

By CAROL SMITH
P-I REPORTER

SNOHOMISH -- The cannon shot that ripped into Brett Karch's leg, causing a gaping combat-style wound, has also torn a hole in his hometown community of Snohomish.

Karch, whose leg was nearly amputated and who faces more than a year of physical rehabilitation with an uncertain outcome, has been the target of physical threats because of fears his injury will jeopardize the community's tradition of firing the ceremonial cannon before each high school football game and after touchdowns.

For more than 30 years, the blast of the cherry-red cannon has ignited the roars of fans whenever the home team scored in this football-proud town. With its tree-lined streets, gingerbread-trimmed Victorian houses and hills crested with historic churches, the town is devoted to its traditions, including its beloved cannon, which students in the school's metal shop built after a previous cannon gave out in the mid-1980s.

Football and the cannon were entwined, like popcorn at the movies. And football and Snohomish were even more so.

"Football is a huge part of the community," said Paula McVey, mother of a Snohomish student. "When there's a game on, you can hear it going from anywhere in town."

Shooting off the cannon was the town's salute to the game that launched many notable football careers and entertained generations.

But the shot that nearly took off Brett Karch's leg now leaves the fate of that tradition in the air, and that has upset some in the community.

According to Karch's medical records, security guards notified police after Karch received disturbing phone calls and visits from parents and students, some of whom threatened to "break his other leg" or worse, if he didn't keep quiet about the accident. Hospital staff had to move him to a secure room where they monitored visitors.

Callers and visitors told Karch they would "make sure his other leg got blown off," and that "there would be retaliation" if the family cooperated in an investigation that could end the cannon tradition, said Mary Bissel, Karch's mother. "That's when I kind of got a little upset," Karch said.

The threats also included mention the family would be "banned from the town," Bissell said. She's been warned not to talk to a lawyer, or reporters.

The allegations of threats, as well as the cause of the accident, remain under investigation. Hospital security reported the threats to the Everett Police Department, but police, who came to the hospital to interview Karch and his mother, won't release the incident report, citing the open investigation into the cause of the accident.

Tradition all but gone

The tradition of firing a cannon at football games has all but disappeared in most school districts, which makes this one that much more endearing to its community.

"This one was grandfathered in," said retired Marine Corps. Col. John Mack, who heads the Marine Corps Junior Reserve Officer Training unit at Snohomish High School and is in charge of the squad that fires the cannon. "We're the only school allowed to do it."

Being on the cannon-firing squad was a source of pride for Karch, who joined the ROTC unit last year to help him toward his longtime goal of becoming a Marine. Karch, a lanky, personable 16-year-old, had hoped to do Special Forces reconnaissance work one day.

"Brett wanted to serve his country," said Bissel. "Now we're just hoping he will be able to use his leg. I never imagined this would happen on a football field."

On Oct. 6 -- the night of the Snohomish Panthers big homecoming game against rival Everett High School -- Karch prepared as usual for the firing of the cannon.

He helped roll the coffee table-sized artillery piece to the field where he and two other cadets packed the barrel with about 5 ounces of gunpowder.

With 10 seconds to go before the game, Cadet Alex Brown, 18, the officer in charge of the firing team, began the countdown.

The other cadets stood at attention except Karch, who leaned in, finger at the ready.

"Fire," Brown commanded. Karch pulled the trigger.

The boom, which normally rattled the bleachers, was louder than usual, witnesses said.

The concussion temporarily deafened Brown, who couldn't see through the smoke for several seconds. When the smoke cleared, he saw Karch lying on the ground clutching his left leg.

"I almost thought he was joking, and I going to yell at him, 'It's not funny,' " said Brown. Then he heard Karch's screams.

The cannon was blown apart. Pieces of it landed 30 feet away, some even touching down in the end zone.

"My leg went flying, and I fell on my right side," said Karch. "Kids were staggering around. I looked at my leg and felt it burning."

"Did it blow my leg off, is my leg still attached?" he recalled asking the closest cadet to him. But the deafened student couldn't hear him.

Within seconds, medics and senior officers sprinted to his side. The team of emergency medical technicians standing by in the event of a football injury rushed Karch into a waiting ambulance.

The priority on the playing field, however, was the game, which didn't stop as Karch was carried off the sidelines to an ambulance, witnesses said.

Not much can stop football in this town, where the pride runs deep. The two-time state champions have generated many notable players and coaches over the years. Dick Armstrong was known as the "winningest coach in Washington state high school football history" by the time he retired in 1994. In his 32 seasons as head coach at Snohomish, Armstrong, who died in 1999, racked up 243 wins and won or shared 16 league titles, including 13 in a row.

As play continued, Karch was taken to Providence Everett's Colby Campus, where doctors initially told his stunned mother they weren't sure they could save his leg. Karch has since undergone three surgeries to implant a titanium rod the length of his shin to replace the decimated bone and to graft skin over the shredded tissue. In February, doctors plan to graft bone from his hip into his leg to help it heal.

"My leg was in so many pieces, it was like a jigsaw puzzle," said Karch.

"If this had happened to a football player, you can be sure he would have been airlifted to Harborview," said one parent of a ROTC member, who asked not to be named for fear of reprisals.

Brown, too, was shocked and later angered by the apparent lack of concern for the seriousness of Karch's injury.

Rumors circulated almost immediately among students that Karch must have packed the cannon incorrectly, and some of the cards and comments have suggested that he deserved what happened to him.

Karch said he didn't do anything different that night, a view shared by his ROTC leader Mack, the retired Marine Corps colonel, who said the team follows military protocols for loading and firing the cannon.

Mack had the cannon X-rayed earlier this year. Fred Langer, an attorney representing the family, said those results showed a stress fracture in the metal, although it's not clear yet whether that had any bearing on the explosion.

No decision has been made yet about whether to acquire a new cannon to ensure the tradition continues, said Snohomish High School Principal Diana Plumis.

"We're certainly not getting that one back," she said. "It was obliterated."

No friends at party

That's what seems to worry many of those who have contacted Karch, who has gotten cards indicating the tradition of the cannon is too important to lose.

"Football wouldn't be the same without the big boom at kickoff," wrote one student in a get-well card.

The reaction of some community members has taken the family and its supporters aback.

"Snohomish is usually a pretty tight community," Brown said. "Usually when something like this happens, groups come together. But that didn't happen this time."

Since his discharge from the hospital on Oct. 23, Karch has had only three visitors -- two of them Mack and Brown. And despite invitations to school friends, not a single person other than family attended his 16th birthday celebration in November, Bissell said.

Bissel suspects some of the reaction may be because she retained a lawyer to help her understand legal forms the school district asked her to sign after the accident. She has not filed any legal claims against the school or the district. According to Langer, the school district has been cooperative and has said it plans to establish a fund to pay for Karch's medical expenses.

What Bissel wants for her son, though, is the emotional support of the community they've lived in for a decade.

On a recent school day afternoon, Karch, who has not been able to attend regular classes since the accident, rode past his old school in a cabulance on his way to an Everett clinic for a weekly changing of the thick dressings that wrap his wounds. Kids had spilled out of the school, and he tried to wave to Brown, who drove by.

Karch said later he wondered whether the kids milling around even realized that he was in the ambulance van going by.

The persistent hostility, and loss of friendships, make him sad, but he's trying not to dwell on it.

He's working hard during weekly physical and occupational therapy sessions, hoping to regain enough function to qualify for the military.

McVey has tried rallying support for Karch's family by raising money for dinners. Her initial attempts raised $200, nearly all of it coming from schools other than Karch's own.

The lack of response still puzzles her.

"You have a kid here who's lost part of his leg, who may always have a rod in it," she said. "Where's the compassion? How would these guys feel if it were their son? Would the cannon really matter?"
Click to expand...

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/296584_cannon20.html?source=mypi

People never fail to disgust me.

Random Autobot · Dec 20, 2006

Damn, we're a selfish bunch of philistines in this here 21st century.

flamepanther · Dec 20, 2006

Just for that, I hope they ban football in that town, not just the cannon. What a bunch of idiotic maniacs.

Kickback · Dec 20, 2006

The only thing dumber than this is if Konami released MGS4 on the 360.

*runs out of the thread*

flamepanther · Dec 20, 2006

Kickback said:

The only thing dumber than this is if Konami released MGS4 on the 360.

*runs out of the thread*
Click to expand...

Don't say that, or I'll break your leg!

Jux · Dec 20, 2006

flamepanther said:

Just for that, I hope they ban football in that town, not just the cannon. What a bunch of idiotic maniacs.
Click to expand...

Yes, good idea. Let's ban a sport that really has no bearing on the incident at hand.

Rodimus Prime · Dec 20, 2006

flamepanther said:

Don't say that, or I'll break your leg!
Click to expand...

Don't you mean shoot/blow up his leg?

Yes, good idea. Let's ban a sport that really has no bearing on the incident at hand.
Click to expand...

He said for the town, so I'm guessing he meant it more as a slap in the face for the dumbshits caring about football more than a kid's life.

Omnibus Prime · Dec 20, 2006

Buncha freaktards in that town. I'd move...whether I'd gotten my leg blown off or not.

Jux · Dec 20, 2006

Hot Rodimus said:

He said for the town, so I'm guessing he meant it more as a slap in the face for the dumbshits caring about football more than a kid's life.
Click to expand...

The kid was the victim of an unfortunate accident, and now the people are acting like tools about it. Not his fault, and it's not the fault of the hundreds of kids who benefit from playing the sport.

Take away the cannon, whatever, but to cancel a sport because a few people in the town are acting like tools doesn't really benefit anyone.

flamepanther · Dec 20, 2006

Hot Rodimus said:

Don't you mean shoot/blow up his leg?
Click to expand...

Nope.

article said:

According to Karch's medical records, security guards notified police after Karch received disturbing phone calls and visits from parents and students, some of whom threatened to "break his other leg" or worse, if he didn't keep quiet about the accident. Hospital staff had to move him to a secure room where they monitored visitors.
Click to expand...

Hot Rodimus said:

He said for the town, so I'm guessing he meant it more as a slap in the face for the dumbshits caring about football more than a kid's life.
Click to expand...

Bingo. Ban them from the sport they're dementedly obsessed over. Let everyone else play.

Jux · Dec 20, 2006

flamepanther said:

Nope.Bingo. Ban them from the sport they're dementedly obsessed over. Let everyone else play.
Click to expand...

You said ban the sport. Which means no one plays.

Rodimus Prime · Dec 20, 2006

Jux said:

The kid was the victim of an unfortunate accident, and now the people are acting like tools about it. Not his fault, and it's not the fault of the hundreds of kids who benefit from playing the sport.

Take away the cannon, whatever, but to cancel a sport because a few people in the town are acting like tools doesn't really benefit anyone.
Click to expand...

I didn't get the feel it was a few people. All of his friends abandoned him and apparently no one cares enough to make donations towards him for this. Seems like it's more than just a few.

Er... he said ban football IN that town. I.E. take them out of the HS league. I don't see it affecting hundreds of kids.

flamepanther · Dec 20, 2006

Jux said:

You said ban the sport. Which means no one plays.
Click to expand...

me said:

Just for that, I hope they ban football in that town...
Click to expand...

Dunno how much clearer I can make it. Nobody in that town would get to play football in said town anymore. Everyone else would.

Hot Rodimus said:

I didn't get the feel it was a few people. All of his friends abandoned him and apparently no one cares enough to make donations towards him for this. Seems like it's more than just a few.
Click to expand...

I got the same impression, and it's a small town to begin with. Even if that wasn't the case, if football were banned there entirely because of those who made the threats, maybe the ire and contempt of their peers would be turned against them instead of an innocent victim of a stupid tradition.

Jux · Dec 20, 2006

flamepanther said:

Dunno how much clearer I can make it. Nobody in that town would get to play football in said town anymore. Everyone else would.
Click to expand...

Well good to clear that up. I then refer you to my original reply. Banning a sport would not really benefit anyone. In fact, it could even push these people with a radical view even further. Poor kid getting threats because there's no more cannon? Imagine if there were no more sport.

It needs to be dealt with, yes, but in a practical manner. Not a knee-jerk reaction like you're suggesting.

flamepanther · Dec 20, 2006

Jux said:

Well good to clear that up. I then refer you to my original reply. Banning a sport would not really benefit anyone. In fact, it could even push these people with a radical view even further. Poor kid getting threats because there's no more cannon? Imagine if there were no more sport.

It needs to be dealt with, yes, but in a practical manner. Not a knee-jerk reaction like you're suggesting.
Click to expand...

I didn't have in mind for it to be a permanent ban. Until the culprits come forward and accept legal punishment might be appropriate. Obviously, those responsible will have a strong vested interest in helping to lift the ban as soon as possible. Schools institute blanket punishments like that all the time when the perpetrators are anonymous. If these people are going to be this immature, let them have a punishment suitable for children.

Rodimus Prime · Dec 20, 2006

I agree it's not pratical, but I figured he was just letting of steam. It's a pretty ******ed response by the whole town.

Cheetatron · Dec 20, 2006

The whole story is pretty sad

Being on the cannon-firing squad was a source of pride for Karch, who joined the ROTC unit last year to help him toward his longtime goal of becoming a Marine. Karch, a lanky, personable 16-year-old, had hoped to do Special Forces reconnaissance work one day.
Click to expand...

The kid wanted to be a Force Recon Marine? I guess that dream got shot to shit

Heh

*unhinged* Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh Heh

Jux · Dec 20, 2006

flamepanther said:

I didn't have in mind for it to be a permanent ban. Until the culprits come forward and accept legal punishment might be appropriate. Obviously, those responsible will have a strong vested interest in helping to lift the ban as soon as possible. Schools institute blanket punishments like that all the time when the perpetrators are anonymous. If these people are going to be this immature, let them have a punishment suitable for children.
Click to expand...

Do you have any example where such a knee jerk reaction was successful?

I doubt you can find more than one or two. Because it's not practical. In the meantime, while you're going after a handful of people who aren't going to come forward ("yeah, you're right, arrest me for assault officer, just let the kids play again!"), you're punishing many more people who do benefit from playing competitive sports.

flamepanther · Dec 20, 2006

Jux said:

Do you have any example where such a knee jerk reaction was successful?

I doubt you can find more than one or two. Because it's not practical. In the meantime, while you're going after a handful of people who aren't going to come forward ("yeah, you're right, arrest me for assault officer, just let the kids play again!"), you're punishing many more people who do benefit from playing competitive sports.
Click to expand...

If you're wanting an article on it, that's not terribly likely. It happened a few times at my college though. In cases where the guilty party or parties didn't come forward, it pressured witnesses or accomplices to smoke them out, so to speak. There was nothing on the level of banning an entire sport, but there were no problems on the level of threats of physical harm either.

Jux · Dec 20, 2006

So what happens when football is banned, and now the kid is receiving threats for not only the cannon being gone, but now their favorite sport as well?

Log in or Sign up

Accident in football town elicited threats, not get-well wishes

Rodimus Prime Sola Gratia, Sola Fide TFW2005 Supporter

Random Autobot Soviet Kanukistani

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Kickback @GeekWithChris Administrator News Staff

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

Rodimus Prime Sola Gratia, Sola Fide TFW2005 Supporter

Omnibus Prime I'm too old for this shit TFW2005 Supporter

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

Rodimus Prime Sola Gratia, Sola Fide TFW2005 Supporter

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Rodimus Prime Sola Gratia, Sola Fide TFW2005 Supporter

Cheetatron Drat, outsmarted by a Lorry, I am disgraced

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

Log in or Sign up

Accident in football town elicited threats, not get-well wishes

Rodimus Prime Sola Gratia, Sola Fide TFW2005 Supporter

Random Autobot Soviet Kanukistani

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Kickback @GeekWithChris Administrator News Staff

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

Rodimus Prime Sola Gratia, Sola Fide TFW2005 Supporter

Omnibus Prime I'm too old for this shit TFW2005 Supporter

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

Rodimus Prime Sola Gratia, Sola Fide TFW2005 Supporter

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Rodimus Prime Sola Gratia, Sola Fide TFW2005 Supporter

Cheetatron Drat, outsmarted by a Lorry, I am disgraced

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

flamepanther Interested, but not really

Jux Please, call me Steve. Veteran

Useful Searches