New Doctor Who

...Absolute crap. Irredeemable drivel.
TRY HARDER, DAVIES.

i still cant stand donna, she over-tips the camp aspects of doctor who.

but i was damn suprised by the ending bit,.

Good opening to the series never expected Rose at the end though, shocker! 'Bees have gone missing' was a good reference to one of the future episodes. Great episode 9/10.

Ratchet2007

The ending was a suprise - not sure yet if it's a good one or not.

Not impressed with much else of the episode though. Typical RTD really.

Last night's Torchwood was better.

I was shocked when they killed off Toshiko and Owen.....Again !

Anyway I'm I the only one who is gettin sick of the Daleks ? It's as if they have to be in every season! Anyone else agree ?

Ratchet2007

From the looks of it, the Daleks returning is the only thing that would redeem this series to me.

What a freaking letdown. What is it with TV this week; Torchwood, Doctor Who and TFA were all real dissapointments to me. I don't know, maybe I'm expecting too much.

Nevermind, I'll most likely keep watching, but frankly, Tate is almost enough for me to skip this altogether anyway. Nevermind, Sontarans, Ood and Daleks, that's gotta be worth sticking around for right? ...right?

I just can't stand Tate. Whenever she was on screen she just seemed to be playing one of her awful characters. I just can't accept her as a 'serious' actress.
The fat creatures looked so fake too.

And I'm sure everyone knew Donna was gonna show her grandfather the Tardis in some way at the end. It was like writing by numbers.

And was that 'bin' bit supposed to be some kind of joke as if from her teen character? 'Bin there'?

The only decent bit was Rose.

WTF!!!!! if you don't like the show quit watching it and quit bad mouthing it doctor who kicks ass. tate is a bitch get over it she is starring in the 4th season for a few episodes but don't worry rose is coming back in middle of the season and martha will be back as well

I found it to be a fairly light hearted episode. Not the best, but certainly not the worse.
I wasn't to keen on the idea of the return of Donna, but I actually found her to be not as annoying as I thought she was. She doesn't seem to be all droopy eyes for the Doctor, and actually might be someone that can match him. Though whether it stays like this through the rest of the series remains to be seen.

The re-meeting between the two was humorous.

The nods to earlier episodes were good as well, plus a little nod to Torchwood (which has been a much better second series) and Donna's comment about the Doctor not killing these children.

I did know Rose was coming back, however I didn't know she'd show up in the first episode. Very interesting and wondering where this will lead.

Lets see if next week can remain the same or better.

Chaos was the law of nature; order was the dream of man. Henry Brooks Adams, American Historian (1838 - 1918)

To be honest, Tate was the only good thing about the episode.
And I can't believe I just wrote that, but it's true.
And yes, Torchwood season 2 was a massive improvement on season 1. I hope they keep it up.